0000501: Close minimizes to System try

(0001152)
Kry (manager)
2005-07-18 02:54

I am sorry but I don't agree with this. For me, close button is for
closing, and minimize button is for minimizing.

Making the default behaviour for a button change is confusing to say the
least. I get easily annoyed by apps that doesn't close when I hit the
"Close" button. I hate to go to File->Quit, and what's even better,
aMule has no other way to quit than the close button.

So that's a "no" from me.

(0001153)
fax8 (reporter)
2005-07-18 18:40

this shouldn't be the default but only
an option on the settings.

For me it's useful because:
how many times a day you want to close amule?
maybe not one couse probably you never close amule couse if
you close it you will lose queue priority on downloads.

how many times you want only see amule for a while and then
send it to background?

I do it lot of times.

(0001154)
Xaignar (manager)
2005-07-18 23:11

Close is Close and Minimize is Minimize. Why do you insist on mixing up the functionality and just not use the minimize button? aMule has the ability to minimize to the tray, so you can easily hide it when you arn't using it.

(0001156)
Kry (manager)
2005-07-19 12:05

I'll quote myself:

"aMule has no other way to quit than the close button"

(0001157)
fax8 (reporter)
2005-07-19 21:10

Ok.. you are the boss!

I will continue click on x with
azureus, apollon, gaim, kopete,
kaffeine, noautumn, amarok, kbear,
juk, kget, kmail, kscd, akregator...

but still minus with aMule.

:-)

Keep on the wonderful work!

(0001160)
Kry (manager)
2005-07-20 10:27

We're all happy and we all agree, and we all go to drink beer, and I close this ;)

Notes
(0001152) Kry (manager) 2005-07-18 02:54	I am sorry but I don't agree with this. For me, close button is for closing, and minimize button is for minimizing. Making the default behaviour for a button change is confusing to say the least. I get easily annoyed by apps that doesn't close when I hit the "Close" button. I hate to go to File->Quit, and what's even better, aMule has no other way to quit than the close button. So that's a "no" from me.

(0001153) fax8 (reporter) 2005-07-18 18:40	this shouldn't be the default but only an option on the settings. For me it's useful because: how many times a day you want to close amule? maybe not one couse probably you never close amule couse if you close it you will lose queue priority on downloads. how many times you want only see amule for a while and then send it to background? I do it lot of times.

(0001154) Xaignar (manager) 2005-07-18 23:11	Close is Close and Minimize is Minimize. Why do you insist on mixing up the functionality and just not use the minimize button? aMule has the ability to minimize to the tray, so you can easily hide it when you arn't using it.

(0001156) Kry (manager) 2005-07-19 12:05	I'll quote myself: "aMule has no other way to quit than the close button"

(0001157) fax8 (reporter) 2005-07-19 21:10	Ok.. you are the boss! I will continue click on x with azureus, apollon, gaim, kopete, kaffeine, noautumn, amarok, kbear, juk, kget, kmail, kscd, akregator... but still minus with aMule. :-) Keep on the wonderful work!

(0001160) Kry (manager) 2005-07-20 10:27	We're all happy and we all agree, and we all go to drink beer, and I close this ;)

Issue History
Date Modified	Username	Field	Change
2005-07-17 20:03	fax8	New Issue
2005-07-18 02:54	Kry	Note Added: 0001152
2005-07-18 18:40	fax8	Note Added: 0001153
2005-07-18 23:11	Xaignar	Note Added: 0001154
2005-07-19 12:05	Kry	Note Added: 0001156
2005-07-19 21:10	fax8	Note Added: 0001157
2005-07-20 10:27	Kry	Status	new => assigned
2005-07-20 10:27	Kry	Assigned To	=> Kry
2005-07-20 10:27	Kry	Status	assigned => closed
2005-07-20 10:27	Kry	Note Added: 0001160

Relationships